Bright entryway with a cushioned bench beneath a staircase with wood treads and dark railings.

Nantucket Real Estate Snapshot for May 2025

June 2, 2025

Fisher Real Estate May 2025 market snapshot: $54.3M sales, 20 transactions, 16 contracts, and 180 listings.

May 2025 Market Snapshot

“After four consecutive months of double-digit increases from 2024 data, preliminary May transaction data points to a similar number of property sales from one year ago but a 21 percent decline in volume. This is due to lower dollar volume sales in May 2025 compared to May 2024, particularly in the $4 million to $6 million segment. Nonetheless, due to the strength in the first part of the year, YTD sales remain 49 percent higher on a transaction basis and 32 percent on a dollar volume basis. New contract activity declined by three contracts from April but wasn’t too shabby considering the stock market volatility during the same period. New listing inventory increased by nearly 52 properties but remained almost the same as one year ago, based on the pace of sales. Stay tuned for our full May report.”

Nantucket April-to-May 2025 real estate market comparison with listing, agreement, price-change, and sales totals.

May 2025 Nantucket Real Estate Listing Updates

New Listings

$1,050,000 30B Evergreen Way
$1,395,000 2A Forrest Avenue
$1,395,000 2B Forrest Avenue
$1,695,000 7 Back Street
$1,750,000 3 Newtown Road
$1,945,000 21 Bank Street
$1,950,000 11 Perry Lane
$1,975,000 10 South Pasture Lane
$2,075,000 2 Elbow Lane
$2,295,000 91 Goldfinch Drive
$2,395,000 249 Madaket Road
$2,400,000 9 Correia Lane
$2,450,000 16 Atlantic Avenue
$2,495,000 6 Maple Lane
$2,595,000 17 Goldfinch Drive
$2,895,000 14 Mamack Lane
$2,950,000 21R Vestal Street
$2,995,000 32 Hooper Farm Road
$2,995,000 19 Vesper Lane
$3,075,000 47 West Chester Street
$3,150,000 40 Shell Street
$3,195,000 12 Ipswich Street (Portion of)
$3,275,000 2 Fawn Lane
$3,750,000 118 B and D Orange Street
$3,950,000 5 Stone Barn Way
$4,595,000 11 Columbus Avenue
$5,000,000 318 Milestone Road
$5,195,000 69 Orange Street
$5,600,000 85 Vestal Street
$5,950,000 4 Sunset Hill Lane
$6,000,000 1 Airport Road
$6,000,000 7 Airport Road
$6,550,000 12 North Pasture Lane
$6,595,000 6 Fargo Way
$6,750,000 86 Cliff Road
$6,825,000 12 Willard Street
$6,895,000 2 Tautemo Way
$7,225,000 6 Mariner Way
$7,500,000 39 Quaise Road
$7,995,000 84 Cliff Road
$8,900,000 2A Morgan Square
$8,995,000 10 White Elephant Way
$9,975,000 3 Tautemo Way
$9,995,000 21 Quidnet Road
$11,995,000 9 Pleasant Street
$11,995,000 15 North Water Street
$11,995,000 1 & 7 Airport Road
$12,500,000 11 Eel Point Road
$16,995,000 14 Bassett Road
$22,750,000 1 Ocean Avenue
$22,995,000 3 Beacon Lane
$34,500,000 52 Monomoy Road

Under Agreement

$1,495,000 23B West Chester Street
$1,695,000 46 Hooper Farm Road
$1,945,000 21 Bank Street
$1,975,000 10 South Pasture Lane
$1,995,000 9 Goldfinch Drive
$2,999,000 5 Copper Lane
$3,195,000 6 Jonathan Way
$3,275,000 2 Fawn Lane
$3,500,000 5 Gray Avenue
$4,000,000 6 Fawn Lane
$4,200,000 5 Emily Street
$5,495,000 15 Delaney Road
$6,595,000 6 Fargo Way
$6,895,000 8 Winn Street
$6,995,000 3 Old Farm Road
$12,325,000 20 Bishops Rise

Price Changes

$1,694,000 121A Orange Street
$1,795,000 3 Yawkey Way
$2,275,000 14 Lyon Street
$2,375,000 15C Correia Lane
$3,695,000 7 White Street
$3,750,000 118 B and D Orange Street
$4,000,000 9 Green Hollow Road
$4,500,000 44 Sankaty Road
$5,395,000 50 Hummock Pond Road
$5,695,000 27 North Liberty Street
$12,325,000 20 Bishops Rise

Sold Listings

$400,000 37 Sheep Pond Road
$463,500 2B Anna Drive
$767,500 65A Surfside Road
$1,100,000 14 Arkansas Avenue
$1,195,000 1A Park Circle
$1,442,000 19 Clarendon Street
$1,550,000 25 Fairgrounds Road
$1,830,000 26B Evergreen Way
$1,900,000 2 L Street
$1,967,500 1 Arkansas Avenue
$2,000,000 29 Sesapana Road
$2,150,000 4 Wood Hollow Road
$2,200,000 26 Creek Lane
$2,549,000 11 Sesapana Road
$2,560,000 27 Long Pond Drive
$2,595,000 27 Old South Road
$3,144,375 44 Madaket Road
$3,652,000 2 Cabot Lane
$6,595,000 6 Fargo Way
$14,250,000 7 Weetamo Road

Market Insight

Weathered cedar-shingled home with white-trimmed windows, a covered entry and a bluestone walk across an autumn lawn.

Madaket Harbor Came Up Short on Opening Day. The Island's Scallop Shortage Is Somewhere Else.

Weathered cedar-shingled home with a white-trimmed window, pale blue glazed door and teak bench on a raised wooden porch.

The Point of Breakers Wreck Lost Its Name and Gained a Tag

Weathered cedar-shingled home with a blue-gray entry door, white porch column, silvered decking and autumn beach plum beside a granite-edged walk.

Cisco Beach's Retreat From the Bluff Is Stalled on Two Fronts This Fall

Silver-gray shingle house with a steep gable, three sash windows, and dune grass beside a sandy path.

The Building at the End of the Surfside Path Has Finally Stopped Waiting

Marble kitchen island with seafoam cabinetry, a patinated brass faucet, rosemary, and stacked blue and cream bowls.

What's Actually New About This Year's Nantucket Restaurant Week

Weathered porch overlooking a broad lawn, fieldstone path, rose-hip hedge, and calm water beyond a stone wall.

Brant Point Waterfront Mooring Rights: What Buyers Should Know

Salt grasses and a diagonal boardwalk overlook a tidal channel, dune ridge, and shingled coastal home.

Hummock Pond Opens to the Ocean Twice a Year. The Water Isn't What You're Watching For.

Weathered shingle-style coastal house with a brick-red chimney beyond a meadow and curving gravel drive.

Tupancy Links Never Closes to Dogs. Here's Why Its Rules Differ from Other Nantucket Preserves.

Silver-gray shingle estate with a wraparound porch, brick chimney, and broad lawn beneath a mature oak canopy.

On Baxter Road, the Boundary That Sets Your Price Isn't the Bluff Edge

The Nantucket move starts with a real conversation

Whether you're a year out or a week out, the right time to talk is before the listing hits the market. I respond to every inquiry personally, usually within 24 hours.

Start the Conversation